Judging Effectiveness

Question:
You often talk about effectiveness. In our company, we measure results. How do you measure effectiveness?

Response:
Effectiveness is a matter of judgment. Effectiveness is a matter of managerial judgment. How well does the team member perform in the achievement of the desired goal? Given all the ins and outs, the difficulties faced, the unanticipated, unplanned monkey wrenches that get in the way, how well does the team member perform?

This is a matter of managerial judgment.

Two assumptions:
1. Any task (or role) requires a certain capability.
2. The person assigned to the task or role has the appropriate capability.

The judgment is whether the person is committing full capability to the task (or role).

This is NOT a “matter of counting outputs, super credits for super outputs, or penalties for lateness or sub-standard quality.” * This is about bringing full capability to the completion of the task.

It is the job of the manager to observe and account for all the surrounding circumstances and make this most important judgment. And it is precisely this judgment that most managers avoid.

*Elliott Jaques, Requisite Organization, 1989.

One thought on “Judging Effectiveness

  1. Edward Burke

    Lets assume in a given role the Key Results Areas have been defined. The person is exhibiting the Time Span, and results in these areas. I would say they are capable … what am i missing.
    I realize there is another fit in regards to core values/culture fit (Right Person), but as far as ‘capability’ (right Seat) what else and how to evaluate this?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *