Now we were getting somewhere. “Something would change?” I repeated.

“Well, yes,” Walter started. “We could do the same thing over and over, and be successful, until something changed.”

“So, when we talk about planning, what would be valuable to talk about. Where is the real value in planning?”

Walter was still hoping he hadn’t painted himself into a corner. “You’re right. The real value in planning is talking about what will change. Maybe that is what is unsettling about the process. We talk about change, things that might happen or might not happen, things we don’t know about. Then we attach a revenue number to it, like we are the most accurate weather forecaster in the world. That is the unsettling part.”

“Are you trying to do two things at cross purpose?”

Walter nodded again, “Yes, we talk about the uncertainty of the future and then try to nail down a black and white number all in the same sentence.”

“So, what good is planning?” I repeated. “What would happen if we did NO planning?”

“You know, that’s a great question. I don’t know that anything would change. To know what to do, tomorrow, we just have to look at what we did yesterday.”

“So, just look at yesterday, do the same thing again and we can expect the same result?” I summarized.

Walter nodded his head and chuckled, “Pretty much. And at the end of the year, our revenue number would be about the same, hopefully a little better.”

“So, how long could you keep that up?” I prodded. “I mean, successfully doing the same thing over and over and over? Could you do that, forever?”

“Well, not forever,” Walter smiled. “At some point, something will change.”

“Something will change?” I asked.

“Then, what’s the purpose?” I prodded. “What is the purpose for planning? What is the value, spending two days jabbering?”

Walter was quietly making sure he hadn’t painted himself into a corner. “Okay, the planning process has virtue. But the process is unsettling. We call it strategic planning, but I don’t think we talk much about strategy. We try to create an annual revenue number and then talk about why the production line broke down last week. That’s not strategy.”

“So, talking about the production line is unsettling?” I asked.

“No. We can talk about the production line. It’s just that planning is a discussion about the future. We are supposed to create this vision of the future, but we talk about stuff that happened last week. And no matter how great we paint this picture of the future, the production line will always break down, or our customer’s project will be delayed, or a competitor will come in with a cheaper price. What good is planning?”

“Here we go, again,” Walter shook his head. “The obligatory offsite strategic planning meeting.”

“I can tell you are not excited about the planning process,” I responded.

“It’s just that we spend two days jabbering, write some goals on a flip chart and then forget about it. It’s not that I don’t like the process, it’s just, at the end of the day, I don’t see the value.”

“You don’t see the value in jabbering, writing goals or following up? Which is it?” I asked.

“I mean, we create a revenue goal. It’s a nice number. But whether we reach that goal, has little to do with the fact that we write the number on a flipchart every December.”

“So, what happened when you shared your plan with the team?” I asked.

Lisa winced. “Share my plan? Well, yes, I was planning to roll it out next week. Should be a big kickoff.”

“So, everyone is on board with the plan?”

“Well, they don’t know about it, yet. I mean, they know about the project, but I plan to share the details during the kickoff,” Lisa assured.

“Lisa, did you discover anything new while you were creating this plan?”

She nodded, “This plan has some wrinkles in it. It will require some specific changes to our process.”

“Why didn’t you know that before the plan?” I pressed.

“I guess I always knew it, but I didn’t see it until I wrote it all out,” Lisa agreed.

“Do you think your team might discover some things when they see the plan all laid out?”

“I suppose.”

“Is there a possibility that those discoveries might wreck your big Kickoff?”

Lisa face revealed a slight stare of anxiety. “You’re right, but I have already scheduled the Kickoff Meeting.”

“So, change the name of the meeting from the Kickoff Meeting to the Plan Review Meeting.”